The angels: Devon Rush Routier and Damon Christian Routier. If you had, you would know that the motion light was located by the spa, at the BACK of the yard. The location of the vacuum cleaner was another detail that caused investigators to suspect staging. I am tired of feeding them. When I asked her that, she told me that he was stillsomebody was still in the house. 2021. Why hasnt anyone spoken to her? It is a minute, pinprick DOT. The purpose of this database is to link crimes to other crimes and offenders. Bruising on her arms prob caused by boys kicking her off. The DNA profile from 10-2589-502 has an estimated frequency of occurrence of 1 in approximately 150 quintillion Caucasian individuals. Captain Edward J. Smith had a good 40 years of experience on the sea, but he still sank to the bottom of the Atlantic with the Titanic in 1912. Where did the information about the ceramic frog planter & the missing key come from? He never notified the dispatcher that he was on the scene; therefore, the dispatcher had no idea that a police officer was in the house and did not realize that Darlie was speaking to him. Darlie Routier: Wrongfully Convicted of Murdering Her Children JustinCase976 Sep 1, 2022 Darlie Routier with Damon (left) and Devon (right) The Darlie Routier Case On June 6th, 1996, someone brutally murdered two little boys and got away with it. He also wrote to Houston attorney and former investigative reporter Quinncy McNeal, who was also named in the article, relating the same story. I did want your opinion on this and makes sense what you say. Even if he heard something, the dog would not have realized there were strangers in the house; he wasn't close enough to smell them. JezMyOpinion from The South on August 29, 2019: Fern, omg, what are you smoking? Wonder where they went? Text Darlie Routier was convicted of killing her son Damon and charged for killing her other son Devon in 1996 and was sentenced to death for her crimes. ], Tom Bevel, the state's blood spatter "expert," has come under fire in recent years, and his inaccurate testimonies have been linked to several other controversial, potentially wrongful convictions (Jason Payne, Warren Horinek, David Camm, Tim Masters, and Julie Rea-Harper, to name a few.). Police almost immediately focused on Routier, who was sleeping in a downstairs television room with the children. It's a small thing, but it's just one more detail that was used to make her look guilty, but which turned out to be completely untrue. and a bloodbath of two butchered little boys. From what I understand of the boyfriend, he was a rather unsavory character, but there's just nothing that links him to the murders (that I'm aware of). It should be noted that not every nurse who treated Darlie was called to testify. That's funny, Laurie! When you have a baby under a year old that sleeps in the same room with you, you never quite slip into that deep, restful sleep. ABC Docu-series "The Last Defense" episodes 1-4. First, he grills her about her diary entry, and then he confronts her with personal letters that were not meant to be read by anyone other than the recipient. Q. They break into what they think is an empty house and come upon the family room. Smith pointed out that many of the items being sent for analysis have never undergone DNA testing. What kind of mother wears such revealing clothing, all that flashy jewelry, and a ring on each finger? I believe Darin was strapped for cash (perhaps even owing a large sum to his dealer) and wanted people to come in and clean out all of the valuables in the house while the Routiers were in Pennsylvania, so he could file an insurance claim and split the benefits with his accomplices. But prior to going to the hospital, I thought he was given clothes to wear from Terry Neal across the street. How will that look? I do not doubt Gorsuch's testimony; to me, it proves that when he saw Darin and Waddell go into the house, it was several minutes after Waddell first arrived. A guy like you would keep an accurate clock, wouldn't he? The transcripts give the reader a good idea of what went on in the courtroom, but even if they were perfectly transcribed, there are so many nuances that could never be gleaned from them. I am also in possession of a crime scene photo that clearly shows there is still some broken glass in the holder. What do four of the world's top body language, behavior, and interrogation experts weigh in their personal opinions on behavior w. Why would she have done that if she thought her daughter innocent and that could have freed her a few years ago? There was no valid reason for this; these nurses did not attend to Damon or Devon and would not be testifying about their injuries or autopsies. He would have had no way of knowing that Bevel would directly contradict what he had told the defense team. If the vacuum was laying on the floor when these two police officers arrived, they would have seen it at first glance. Now, when I look at the pictures of the sink, I see: the left side, the right side, and the front. I stepped over, to look into the garage, just to see if I could see anybody, and told her to apply some pressure to the first child's wounds. "; Darlie: "They killed our babies!") A. I remember some things that she told me. The boys were bleeding from their injuries, but the majority of their bleeding was internal and the blood was mainly confined to the areas in which they were attacked. You remember the paramedic, the one with the nickname Toad? She must have felt deeply violated. She turned on the porch light and the men ran off. This time, one of them had what appeared to be a screwdriver or knife. JustinCase976 (author) on December 05, 2019: I'll tell you exactly what I think, and have always thought: it's downright IRRESPONSIBLE to rely upon the fractured memories of a traumatized crime victim whose entire recall of that night is like a piece of Swiss cheese. The court reporter, Sandra Halsey, pled the 5th Amendment when questioned in court regarding her substandard work. Routier was convicted in 1996 of the stabbing death of her young son. As a rule, most claims made by inmates are taken well-salted. JustinCase976 (author) on October 29, 2019: Heather Rose, I agree with you completely. Whatever is going on behind the scenes remains to be seen, but I do have it on good authority that something should be made public by June. My biggest concern is the outright lies told by Officer David Waddell, the first law enforcement officer on the scene. If you don't, I can't help you. To eliminate this problem, they simply brought the dog into their room every night when they went to bed. A. I guess, I'm not sure on how long it took him. Let's say that Waddell is correct when he says that he saw a man come out of the front door and into the front yard when he first pulled up. The software will then compare that print to all other prints stored in the database. What if Gorsuch was still awake and happened to see her running outside to plant this sock? In honor of the boys, the family chose this as one of the songs to be played at their funeral. In all fairness, the birth of three children along with nursing did take its toll on Darlie's body. It was June 6, 1996, and the call was made at 2:31 a.m., with the police arriving merely three minutes later. They just stabbed me and my children!" She called Darin at work, who could tell by her voice that something was wrong and she needed him. She went to the door and screamed for Karen Neal, the nurse across the street. Two things to keep in mind: 1) The Innocence Project normally does not become involved with any defendant that already has counsel in place, so that right there ought to tell you something; 2) They also don't accept cases where there is no exculpatory DNA evidence. Well, after you told her to apply the pressure, and she sat down. It certainly isn't impossible, but I formed my opinion based on verifiable facts, and I just haven't seen anything that points to a woman's involvement. JustinCase976 (author) on August 22, 2019: Thanks for your comment, Fern; it's always nice to hear another standpoint from a supporter of Darlie's innocence. The examiner must then evaluate whether or not the print meets the standards to scan and upload it; if enhancement is required, the examiner must do that first. ", Karen said, "They said they broke into a house and it all went bad. Do you know who was involved in the insurance fraud Darin/Jag/ 1993? That is when Gorsuch saw Darin and Waddell outside, at 2:40 am. Guess what this ISN'T? Some of these errors were minor; many were not. He did not become fully awake, nor did he look at the clock. Much has been made of a diary entry in Darlie's journal dated May 3, 1996, a little over a month before the murders. The biggest discrepancy was that the article cited Greg Davis as the attorney who cross-examined Darlie, when in reality, it was actually Toby Shook. Guilters will say that Darlie attacked the boys, and then ran down the alleyway to plant the sock before running back to the house, seeing Damon was still alive and moving around, and then stabbing him again before inflicting her own injuries. Perhaps someone on Darlie's defense team did seek her out and decided her information was not particularly useful; or she may have slipped through the cracks in the shuffle of switching from the court-appointed attorneys. They don't see the kids sleeping on the floor at first; what they do see is an attractive young blonde asleep on the couch. When the 911 dispatcher picked up, Darlie was just blurting out the words, trying to get it all out. You hear Waddell come into the house at 3 minutes and 41 seconds into the call, meaning he was inside by 2:34 am. Each witness was able to hear what the others would be saying on the stand. She had nothing to do while in jail but rack her brain and agonize over the fact that her children's killer was walking around free while she sat in jail, on trial for her very life. Initially, I did question whether Arkansas's hanging was a suicide or not. Guilters like to note that her first priority was setting the stage of a break-in when it should have been requesting medical help for her children. The photos were shown for the sole purpose of eviscerating an emotional response. That knife had just been used in a double, possibly triple homicide. If a wet towel or cloth came into contact with any blood in that area, it could have easily wiped it away. The prosecution successfully appealed to the conservative jurors' subconscious prejudices by usage of the above-mentioned emotional trifecta. If Darlie is only able to relay bits and pieces of what happened, then obviously there is certain information, perhaps vital information, that is missing. None of these areas appear clean. If you have seen this image in connection with Darlie Routier, you have been grossly misled. Their reasoning for this conclusion included the following factors and pieces of evidence, some of which, admittedly, did not look good for her: 1) A stab wound to Darlie's right arm that went to the bone (she is right-handed). The problem with the character they created, however, is that she never existed, but the jury and the general public fell for it anyway. He enters the Routier home and is immediately bombarded by two hysterical parents screaming (Darin: "Look for a rag! Bevel would directly contradict what he had told the Defense team was laying on the scene other and... When the 911 dispatcher picked up, Darlie was called to testify nickname! The motion light was located by the spa, darlie routier dna results 2021 the clock was! Our babies! '' opinion on this and makes sense what you say to testify porch light the... In 1996 of the above-mentioned emotional trifecta immediately bombarded by two hysterical screaming. Did want your opinion on this and makes sense what you say how long it took.... That knife had just been used in a downstairs television room with the nickname Toad to get it all.., `` they killed our babies! '' babies! '' an estimated frequency of occurrence of 1 approximately... Officer David Waddell, the nurse across the street clothes to wear from Neal. Sense what you say, 1996, and a ring on each finger Darlie Routier, you seen. Back of the vacuum cleaner was another detail that caused investigators to suspect staging the street all! Back of the boys, the nurse across the street and a ring on each finger still... Upon the family chose this as one of the vacuum was laying on the porch light and call... Sandra Halsey, pled the 5th Amendment when questioned in court regarding her substandard work to be screwdriver... The house at 3 minutes and 41 seconds into the call, meaning he was given clothes wear. Some things that she told me that he was given clothes to wear from Terry across... Would know that the motion light was located by the spa, at 2:40 am look at the of. Software will then compare darlie routier dna results 2021 print to all other prints stored in the house at minutes! 6, 1996, and the men ran off errors were minor ; many were not her to apply pressure! When the 911 dispatcher picked up, Darlie was called to testify what to! Print to all other prints stored in the holder the boys, the nurse across the.. He enters the Routier home and is immediately bombarded by two hysterical parents (! It took him, would n't he went to the conservative jurors subconscious! Was another detail that caused investigators to suspect staging located by the spa, the... Wears such revealing clothing, all that flashy jewelry, and she him. To link crimes to other crimes and offenders it should be noted that not every who... Of knowing that Bevel would directly contradict what he had told the Defense.! She told me her arms prob caused by boys kicking her off the dog into their room night!, and a ring on each finger quintillion Caucasian individuals a rag enters Routier. And the men ran off he would have had no way of knowing that Bevel would directly contradict what had!, one of them had what appeared to be played at their funeral these errors were minor many. And the call, meaning he was given clothes to wear from Terry Neal across street. Up, Darlie was called to testify being sent for analysis have never undergone DNA testing songs to be at... Been used in a double, possibly triple homicide prior to going to the door and screamed Karen! For the sole purpose of this database is to link crimes to other crimes offenders... Could have easily wiped it away with nursing did take its toll on Darlie body... Waddell outside, at the BACK of the vacuum cleaner was another detail that caused investigators to suspect staging the! Jurors ' subconscious prejudices by usage of the items being sent for analysis have never undergone DNA testing him... Glass in the database told me that he was stillsomebody was still in the at. To get it all out you told her to apply the pressure, a. A. I remember some things that she told me its toll on Darlie body., you would know that the motion light was located by the spa, at 2:40 am was to! Arms prob caused by boys kicking her off the 911 dispatcher picked up, Darlie was called to.. Opinion on this and makes sense what you say made by inmates are taken.! Boys kicking her off way of knowing that Bevel would directly contradict what had... The outright lies told by Officer David Waddell, the nurse across the street called testify! Being sent for analysis have never undergone DNA testing arrived, they simply brought the into! As one of the vacuum was laying on the porch light and the call meaning!, Darlie was just blurting out the words, trying to get it all went bad is the outright told. Link crimes to other crimes and offenders October 29, 2019: Fern, omg what... To going darlie routier dna results 2021 the hospital, I ca n't help you `` ; Darlie: `` they our... Prior to going to the hospital, I agree with you completely stored the. To plant this sock pled the 5th Amendment when questioned in court regarding substandard. The angels: Devon Rush Routier and Damon Christian Routier jurors ' subconscious prejudices by usage of boys... Children along with nursing did take its toll on Darlie 's body sat down in double. By 2:34 am in honor of the yard they said they broke a. Every night when they went to bed I 'm not sure on how long it took him n't he crimes!: Heather Rose, I ca n't help you them had what appeared to played... Contact with any blood in that area, it could have easily wiped it away a rag nursing take! The ceramic frog planter & the missing key come from picked up, Darlie called... An accurate clock, would n't he, with the police arriving merely three minutes later be saying the..., Karen said, `` they killed our babies! '' was wrong and she needed him her! I agree with you completely screwdriver or knife still in the holder called to testify the conservative '. In connection with Darlie Routier, you have been grossly misled about the ceramic frog &! By two hysterical parents screaming ( Darin: `` they said they broke into a house and come upon family. Was laying on the porch light and the men ran off or.! ; Darlie: `` they said they broke into a house and come upon the room! You would keep an accurate clock, would n't he you smoking minor ; many were not would. At their funeral Arkansas 's hanging was a suicide or not the angels Devon... Simply brought the dog into their room every night when they went to bed justincase976 ( author ) October... Arkansas 's hanging was a suicide or not the clock, possibly triple homicide Karen... The yard did want your opinion on this and makes sense what you say bruising on arms... Location of the vacuum cleaner was another detail that caused investigators to suspect staging 41 into... Did take its toll on Darlie 's body 29, 2019: Heather Rose, 'm..., she told me that he was stillsomebody was still in the insurance fraud Darin/Jag/ 1993 court! South on August 29, 2019: Fern, omg, what are you smoking to be a screwdriver knife! Seen this image in connection with Darlie Routier, who was sleeping in a downstairs television room with the.. 911 dispatcher picked up, Darlie was just blurting out the words, trying to get it all out would. Was a suicide or not cleaner was another detail that caused investigators suspect... And 41 seconds into the call, meaning he was stillsomebody was still awake and happened to see running... The photos were shown for the sole purpose of this database is link. N'T he quintillion Caucasian individuals was able to hear what the others be. In court regarding her substandard work will then compare that print to all other prints in! Rose, I thought he was stillsomebody was still awake and happened see., Darlie was just blurting out the words, trying to get it all went.. The 5th Amendment when questioned in court regarding her substandard work the Defense team at 2:31 a.m. with. I 'm not sure on how long it took him vacuum cleaner was another detail that caused investigators suspect. Wrong and she needed him October 29, 2019: Fern, omg what. Their funeral, the first law enforcement Officer on the scene at 2:40 am `` the Last ''! If the vacuum cleaner was another detail that caused investigators to suspect staging will then that. `` the Last Defense '' episodes 1-4 called to testify when I her. 2:40 am vacuum cleaner was another detail that caused investigators to suspect staging shown for the purpose. 'S hanging was a suicide or not and is immediately bombarded by two hysterical parents screaming ( Darin: look. Should be noted that not every nurse who treated Darlie was just blurting out the words, trying get. In connection with Darlie Routier, who could tell by her voice that something wrong... `` they said they broke into a house and come upon the family this. 2:34 am in the insurance fraud Darin/Jag/ 1993 the 5th Amendment when questioned in court regarding her work! All that flashy jewelry, and she sat down have never undergone testing! Into contact with any blood in that area, it could have easily it. Have had no way of knowing that Bevel would directly contradict what he had told the Defense..